""" Adaptive Method Selector for Atomizer Optimization This module provides intelligent method selection based on: 1. Problem characteristics (static analysis from config) 2. Early exploration metrics (dynamic analysis from first N trials) 3. Runtime performance metrics (continuous monitoring) Classes: - ProblemProfiler: Analyzes optimization config to extract problem characteristics - EarlyMetricsCollector: Computes metrics from initial FEA trials - AdaptiveMethodSelector: Recommends optimization method and parameters - RuntimeAdvisor: Monitors optimization and suggests pivots Usage: from optimization_engine.core.method_selector import AdaptiveMethodSelector selector = AdaptiveMethodSelector() recommendation = selector.recommend(config_path) print(recommendation['method']) # 'turbo', 'hybrid_loop', 'pure_fea', etc. """ import json import numpy as np from pathlib import Path from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any, Tuple from dataclasses import dataclass, field, asdict from enum import Enum import sqlite3 from datetime import datetime class OptimizationMethod(Enum): """Available optimization methods.""" PURE_FEA = "pure_fea" HYBRID_LOOP = "hybrid_loop" TURBO = "turbo" GNN_FIELD = "gnn_field" @dataclass class ProblemProfile: """Static problem characteristics extracted from config.""" # Design space n_variables: int = 0 variable_names: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) variable_bounds: Dict[str, Tuple[float, float]] = field(default_factory=dict) variable_types: Dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict) # 'continuous', 'discrete', 'categorical' design_space_volume: float = 0.0 # Product of all ranges # Objectives n_objectives: int = 0 objective_names: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) objective_goals: Dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict) # 'minimize', 'maximize' # Constraints n_constraints: int = 0 constraint_types: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) # 'less_than', 'greater_than', 'equal' # Budget estimates fea_time_estimate: float = 300.0 # seconds per FEA run total_budget_hours: float = 8.0 max_fea_trials: int = 0 # Computed from budget # Complexity indicators is_multi_objective: bool = False has_constraints: bool = False expected_nonlinearity: str = "unknown" # 'low', 'medium', 'high', 'unknown' # Neural acceleration hints nn_enabled_in_config: bool = False min_training_points: int = 50 def to_dict(self) -> dict: return asdict(self) @dataclass class EarlyMetrics: """Metrics computed from initial FEA exploration.""" n_trials_analyzed: int = 0 # Objective statistics objective_means: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) objective_stds: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) objective_ranges: Dict[str, Tuple[float, float]] = field(default_factory=dict) coefficient_of_variation: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # std/mean # Correlation analysis objective_correlations: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # pairwise variable_objective_correlations: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]] = field(default_factory=dict) # Feasibility feasibility_rate: float = 1.0 n_feasible: int = 0 n_infeasible: int = 0 # Pareto analysis (multi-objective) pareto_front_size: int = 0 pareto_growth_rate: float = 0.0 # New Pareto points per trial # Response smoothness (NN suitability) response_smoothness: float = 0.5 # 0-1, higher = smoother lipschitz_estimate: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # Variable sensitivity variable_sensitivity: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # Variance-based most_sensitive_variable: str = "" # Clustering design_clustering: str = "unknown" # 'clustered', 'scattered', 'unknown' # NN fit quality (if trained) nn_accuracy: Optional[float] = None # R² or similar nn_mean_error: Optional[Dict[str, float]] = None def to_dict(self) -> dict: return asdict(self) @dataclass class RuntimeMetrics: """Metrics collected during optimization runtime.""" timestamp: str = "" trials_completed: int = 0 # Performance fea_time_mean: float = 0.0 fea_time_std: float = 0.0 fea_failure_rate: float = 0.0 # Progress pareto_size: int = 0 pareto_growth_rate: float = 0.0 best_objectives: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) improvement_rate: float = 0.0 # Best objective improvement per trial # NN performance (if using hybrid/turbo) nn_accuracy: Optional[float] = None nn_accuracy_trend: str = "stable" # 'improving', 'stable', 'declining' nn_predictions_count: int = 0 # Exploration vs exploitation exploration_ratio: float = 0.5 # How much of design space explored def to_dict(self) -> dict: return asdict(self) @dataclass class MethodRecommendation: """Output from the method selector.""" method: str confidence: float # 0-1 parameters: Dict[str, Any] = field(default_factory=dict) reasoning: str = "" alternatives: List[Dict[str, Any]] = field(default_factory=list) warnings: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) def to_dict(self) -> dict: return asdict(self) @dataclass class NNQualityMetrics: """NN surrogate quality metrics with relative thresholds. Key insight: NN error should be compared to the coefficient of variation (CV) of each objective to determine if the NN is learning the physics properly. - If nn_error >> CV → NN is unreliable (not learning, just noise) - If nn_error ≈ CV → NN captures the trend (hybrid recommended) - If nn_error << CV → NN is excellent (turbo viable) """ has_nn_data: bool = False n_validations: int = 0 # Per-objective metrics nn_errors: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # Absolute % error cv_ratios: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # nn_error / (CV * 100) expected_errors: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict) # Based on physics type # Overall quality scores (0-1, higher = better) overall_quality: float = 0.5 turbo_suitability: float = 0.0 hybrid_suitability: float = 0.5 # Physics type classification used objective_types: Dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict) # 'linear', 'smooth', 'nonlinear', 'chaotic' def to_dict(self) -> dict: return asdict(self) class NNQualityAssessor: """Assesses NN surrogate quality relative to problem complexity. Uses physics-based expected error thresholds rather than absolute values. The key metric is the CV ratio: nn_error / coefficient_of_variation. CV Ratio Interpretation: - < 0.5 → NN is excellent (captures physics well beyond noise) - 0.5-1 → NN is good (adds value for exploration) - 1-2 → NN is marginal (use with validation) - > 2 → NN is poor (not learning physics, use FEA) """ # Physics-based expected error thresholds PHYSICS_THRESHOLDS = { 'linear': {'max_error': 2.0, 'cv_ratio_max': 0.5}, # mass, volume - deterministic 'smooth': {'max_error': 5.0, 'cv_ratio_max': 1.0}, # frequency, avg stress 'nonlinear': {'max_error': 10.0, 'cv_ratio_max': 2.0}, # max stress, stiffness 'chaotic': {'max_error': 20.0, 'cv_ratio_max': 3.0}, # contact, buckling, fracture } # Objective name to physics type classification OBJECTIVE_CLASSIFICATION = { # Linear (deterministic, easy to learn) 'mass': 'linear', 'volume': 'linear', 'weight': 'linear', 'area': 'linear', # Smooth (well-behaved, moderate difficulty) 'frequency': 'smooth', 'fundamental_frequency': 'smooth', 'first_frequency': 'smooth', 'avg_stress': 'smooth', 'mean_stress': 'smooth', 'displacement': 'smooth', 'avg_displacement': 'smooth', 'compliance': 'smooth', # Nonlinear (sensitive to details, harder to learn) 'stress': 'nonlinear', 'max_stress': 'nonlinear', 'von_mises': 'nonlinear', 'stiffness': 'nonlinear', 'max_displacement': 'nonlinear', 'strain_energy': 'nonlinear', # Chaotic (highly nonlinear, very hard to learn) 'buckling': 'chaotic', 'contact_force': 'chaotic', 'fracture': 'chaotic', 'fatigue': 'chaotic', } def __init__(self): pass def collect(self, results_dir: Path, objective_names: List[str], early_metrics: EarlyMetrics) -> NNQualityMetrics: """Collect NN quality metrics from validation reports and database. Args: results_dir: Path to 2_results directory objective_names: List of objective names from config early_metrics: EarlyMetrics with coefficient_of_variation data Returns: NNQualityMetrics with quality scores and recommendations """ metrics = NNQualityMetrics() # 1. Try validation_report.json first (most reliable - has explicit FEA comparison) validation_report = results_dir / "validation_report.json" if validation_report.exists(): self._load_from_validation_report(validation_report, metrics, objective_names) # 2. Try turbo_report.json (has per-iteration errors) turbo_report = results_dir / "turbo_report.json" if turbo_report.exists() and not metrics.has_nn_data: self._load_from_turbo_report(turbo_report, metrics, objective_names) # 3. Query Optuna database for nn_error_percent user attributes db_path = results_dir / "study.db" if db_path.exists() and not metrics.has_nn_data: self._load_from_database(db_path, metrics, objective_names) # 4. Compute relative metrics using CV from early_metrics if metrics.has_nn_data and early_metrics.coefficient_of_variation: self._compute_relative_metrics(metrics, early_metrics, objective_names) return metrics def _load_from_validation_report(self, report_path: Path, metrics: NNQualityMetrics, objective_names: List[str]): """Load NN error data from validation_report.json.""" try: with open(report_path) as f: report = json.load(f) metrics.n_validations = report.get('n_validated', 0) # Get average errors per objective avg_errors = report.get('average_errors_percent', {}) if avg_errors: metrics.has_nn_data = True for obj_name in objective_names: # Try exact match or partial match error = avg_errors.get(obj_name) if error is None: # Try partial match (e.g., 'mass' in 'total_mass') for key, val in avg_errors.items(): if obj_name.lower() in key.lower() or key.lower() in obj_name.lower(): error = val break if error is not None: metrics.nn_errors[obj_name] = float(error) except Exception as e: pass # Silently fail, try other sources def _load_from_turbo_report(self, report_path: Path, metrics: NNQualityMetrics, objective_names: List[str]): """Load NN error data from turbo_report.json.""" try: with open(report_path) as f: report = json.load(f) metrics.n_validations = report.get('fea_validations', 0) best_solutions = report.get('best_solutions', []) if best_solutions: metrics.has_nn_data = True # Collect errors from all iterations all_errors = [] for sol in best_solutions: nn_error = sol.get('nn_error', []) if nn_error: all_errors.append(nn_error) if all_errors: # Average across all validations avg_errors = np.mean(all_errors, axis=0) # Map to objective names (turbo only tracks mass, stress typically) for i, obj_name in enumerate(objective_names[:len(avg_errors)]): metrics.nn_errors[obj_name] = float(avg_errors[i]) except Exception as e: pass def _load_from_database(self, db_path: Path, metrics: NNQualityMetrics, objective_names: List[str]): """Load NN error data from Optuna database user attributes.""" try: conn = sqlite3.connect(str(db_path)) cursor = conn.cursor() # Query nn_error_percent from trial_user_attributes cursor.execute(""" SELECT value_json FROM trial_user_attributes WHERE key = 'nn_error_percent' """) all_errors = [] for (value_json,) in cursor.fetchall(): try: errors = json.loads(value_json) if isinstance(errors, list): all_errors.append(errors) except: pass conn.close() if all_errors: metrics.has_nn_data = True metrics.n_validations = len(all_errors) # Average across all validated trials avg_errors = np.mean(all_errors, axis=0) for i, obj_name in enumerate(objective_names[:len(avg_errors)]): metrics.nn_errors[obj_name] = float(avg_errors[i]) except Exception as e: pass def _classify_objective(self, obj_name: str) -> str: """Classify objective by physics type.""" # Check exact match first if obj_name in self.OBJECTIVE_CLASSIFICATION: return self.OBJECTIVE_CLASSIFICATION[obj_name] # Check partial match obj_lower = obj_name.lower() for key, obj_type in self.OBJECTIVE_CLASSIFICATION.items(): if key in obj_lower or obj_lower in key: return obj_type # Default to 'smooth' if unknown return 'smooth' def _compute_relative_metrics(self, metrics: NNQualityMetrics, early_metrics: EarlyMetrics, objective_names: List[str]): """Compute NN error relative to objective variability (CV).""" for obj_name in objective_names: nn_error = metrics.nn_errors.get(obj_name) if nn_error is None: continue cv = early_metrics.coefficient_of_variation.get(obj_name, 0.1) # Compute CV ratio (nn_error is %, cv is fraction) # CV ratio = how many times larger is NN error than natural variability if cv > 0.001: cv_ratio = nn_error / (cv * 100) else: # Very low CV means linear/deterministic - use absolute error cv_ratio = nn_error / 2.0 # Normalize to 2% baseline metrics.cv_ratios[obj_name] = cv_ratio # Classify and store obj_type = self._classify_objective(obj_name) metrics.objective_types[obj_name] = obj_type metrics.expected_errors[obj_name] = self.PHYSICS_THRESHOLDS[obj_type]['max_error'] # Compute overall quality scores self._compute_quality_scores(metrics) def _compute_quality_scores(self, metrics: NNQualityMetrics): """Compute overall quality scores based on relative metrics.""" if not metrics.cv_ratios: return quality_scores = [] turbo_scores = [] hybrid_scores = [] for obj_name, cv_ratio in metrics.cv_ratios.items(): obj_type = metrics.objective_types.get(obj_name, 'smooth') threshold = self.PHYSICS_THRESHOLDS[obj_type] # Quality: how well does NN error compare to expected max? nn_error = metrics.nn_errors.get(obj_name, 0) expected = threshold['max_error'] # Use sqrt to be less harsh on errors close to threshold quality = max(0, min(1, 1 - (nn_error / expected) ** 0.5)) if expected > 0 else 0.5 quality_scores.append(quality) # Turbo suitability: cv_ratio should be < cv_ratio_max # Lower ratio = better (NN captures more than noise) cv_max = threshold['cv_ratio_max'] turbo = max(0, min(1, 1 - cv_ratio / cv_max)) if cv_max > 0 else 0.5 turbo_scores.append(turbo) # Hybrid suitability: more lenient threshold (2x) # NN just needs to add some value hybrid = max(0, min(1, 1 - cv_ratio / (cv_max * 2))) if cv_max > 0 else 0.5 hybrid_scores.append(hybrid) metrics.overall_quality = float(np.mean(quality_scores)) if quality_scores else 0.5 metrics.turbo_suitability = float(np.mean(turbo_scores)) if turbo_scores else 0.0 metrics.hybrid_suitability = float(np.mean(hybrid_scores)) if hybrid_scores else 0.5 class ProblemProfiler: """Analyzes optimization config to extract problem characteristics.""" def __init__(self): self.profile = ProblemProfile() def analyze(self, config: dict) -> ProblemProfile: """ Analyze optimization config and return problem profile. Args: config: Loaded optimization_config.json dict Returns: ProblemProfile with extracted characteristics """ profile = ProblemProfile() # Extract design variables design_vars = config.get('design_variables', []) profile.n_variables = len(design_vars) # Support both 'parameter' and 'name' keys for variable naming profile.variable_names = [v.get('parameter') or v.get('name') for v in design_vars] volume = 1.0 for var in design_vars: name = var.get('parameter') or var.get('name') # Support both 'bounds' array and 'min'/'max' fields if 'bounds' in var: bounds = var['bounds'] else: bounds = [var.get('min', 0), var.get('max', 1)] profile.variable_bounds[name] = (bounds[0], bounds[1]) profile.variable_types[name] = var.get('type', 'continuous') volume *= (bounds[1] - bounds[0]) profile.design_space_volume = volume # Extract objectives objectives = config.get('objectives', []) profile.n_objectives = len(objectives) profile.objective_names = [o['name'] for o in objectives] # Support both 'goal' and 'direction' keys for objective direction profile.objective_goals = { o['name']: o.get('goal') or o.get('direction', 'minimize') for o in objectives } profile.is_multi_objective = profile.n_objectives > 1 # Extract constraints constraints = config.get('constraints', []) profile.n_constraints = len(constraints) profile.constraint_types = [c.get('type', 'less_than') for c in constraints] profile.has_constraints = profile.n_constraints > 0 # Budget estimates opt_settings = config.get('optimization_settings', {}) profile.fea_time_estimate = opt_settings.get('timeout_per_trial', 300) profile.total_budget_hours = opt_settings.get('budget_hours', 8) if profile.fea_time_estimate > 0: profile.max_fea_trials = int( (profile.total_budget_hours * 3600) / profile.fea_time_estimate ) # Neural acceleration config nn_config = config.get('neural_acceleration', {}) profile.nn_enabled_in_config = nn_config.get('enabled', False) profile.min_training_points = nn_config.get('min_training_points', 50) # Infer nonlinearity from physics type sim_config = config.get('simulation', {}) analysis_types = sim_config.get('analysis_types', []) if 'modal' in analysis_types or 'frequency' in str(analysis_types).lower(): profile.expected_nonlinearity = 'medium' elif 'nonlinear' in str(analysis_types).lower(): profile.expected_nonlinearity = 'high' else: profile.expected_nonlinearity = 'low' # Static linear self.profile = profile return profile def analyze_from_file(self, config_path: Path) -> ProblemProfile: """Load config from file and analyze.""" with open(config_path) as f: config = json.load(f) return self.analyze(config) class EarlyMetricsCollector: """Computes metrics from initial FEA exploration trials.""" def __init__(self, min_trials: int = 20): self.min_trials = min_trials self.metrics = EarlyMetrics() def collect(self, db_path: Path, objective_names: List[str], variable_names: List[str], constraints: List[dict] = None) -> EarlyMetrics: """ Collect metrics from study database. Args: db_path: Path to study.db objective_names: List of objective column names variable_names: List of design variable names constraints: List of constraint definitions from config Returns: EarlyMetrics with computed statistics """ metrics = EarlyMetrics() if not db_path.exists(): return metrics # Load data from Optuna database conn = sqlite3.connect(str(db_path)) cursor = conn.cursor() try: # Get completed trials from Optuna database # Note: Optuna stores params in trial_params and objectives in trial_values cursor.execute(""" SELECT trial_id FROM trials WHERE state = 'COMPLETE' """) completed_trials = cursor.fetchall() metrics.n_trials_analyzed = len(completed_trials) if metrics.n_trials_analyzed < self.min_trials: conn.close() return metrics # Extract trial data from trial_params and trial_values tables trial_data = [] for (trial_id,) in completed_trials: values = {} # Get parameters cursor.execute(""" SELECT param_name, param_value FROM trial_params WHERE trial_id = ? """, (trial_id,)) for name, value in cursor.fetchall(): try: values[name] = float(value) if value is not None else None except: pass # Get objectives from trial_values cursor.execute(""" SELECT objective, value FROM trial_values WHERE trial_id = ? """, (trial_id,)) for idx, value in cursor.fetchall(): if idx < len(objective_names): values[objective_names[idx]] = float(value) if value is not None else None if values: trial_data.append(values) if not trial_data: conn.close() return metrics # Compute objective statistics for obj_name in objective_names: obj_values = [t.get(obj_name) for t in trial_data if t.get(obj_name) is not None] if obj_values: metrics.objective_means[obj_name] = np.mean(obj_values) metrics.objective_stds[obj_name] = np.std(obj_values) metrics.objective_ranges[obj_name] = (min(obj_values), max(obj_values)) if metrics.objective_means[obj_name] != 0: metrics.coefficient_of_variation[obj_name] = ( metrics.objective_stds[obj_name] / abs(metrics.objective_means[obj_name]) ) # Compute correlations between objectives if len(objective_names) >= 2: for i, obj1 in enumerate(objective_names): for obj2 in objective_names[i+1:]: vals1 = [t.get(obj1) for t in trial_data] vals2 = [t.get(obj2) for t in trial_data] # Filter out None values paired = [(v1, v2) for v1, v2 in zip(vals1, vals2) if v1 is not None and v2 is not None] if len(paired) > 5: v1, v2 = zip(*paired) corr = np.corrcoef(v1, v2)[0, 1] metrics.objective_correlations[f"{obj1}_vs_{obj2}"] = corr # Compute variable-objective correlations (sensitivity) for var_name in variable_names: metrics.variable_objective_correlations[var_name] = {} var_values = [t.get(var_name) for t in trial_data] for obj_name in objective_names: obj_values = [t.get(obj_name) for t in trial_data] paired = [(v, o) for v, o in zip(var_values, obj_values) if v is not None and o is not None] if len(paired) > 5: v, o = zip(*paired) corr = abs(np.corrcoef(v, o)[0, 1]) metrics.variable_objective_correlations[var_name][obj_name] = corr # Compute overall variable sensitivity (average absolute correlation) for var_name in variable_names: correlations = list(metrics.variable_objective_correlations.get(var_name, {}).values()) if correlations: metrics.variable_sensitivity[var_name] = np.mean(correlations) if metrics.variable_sensitivity: metrics.most_sensitive_variable = max( metrics.variable_sensitivity, key=metrics.variable_sensitivity.get ) # Estimate response smoothness # Higher CV suggests rougher landscape avg_cv = np.mean(list(metrics.coefficient_of_variation.values())) if metrics.coefficient_of_variation else 0.5 metrics.response_smoothness = max(0, min(1, 1 - avg_cv)) # Feasibility analysis if constraints: n_feasible = 0 for trial in trial_data: feasible = True for constraint in constraints: c_name = constraint.get('name') c_type = constraint.get('type', 'less_than') threshold = constraint.get('threshold') value = trial.get(c_name) if value is not None and threshold is not None: if c_type == 'less_than' and value > threshold: feasible = False elif c_type == 'greater_than' and value < threshold: feasible = False if feasible: n_feasible += 1 metrics.n_feasible = n_feasible metrics.n_infeasible = len(trial_data) - n_feasible metrics.feasibility_rate = n_feasible / len(trial_data) if trial_data else 1.0 conn.close() except Exception as e: print(f"Warning: Error collecting metrics: {e}") conn.close() self.metrics = metrics return metrics def estimate_nn_suitability(self) -> float: """ Estimate how suitable the problem is for neural network acceleration. Returns: Score from 0-1, higher = more suitable """ score = 0.5 # Base score # Smooth response is good for NN score += 0.2 * self.metrics.response_smoothness # High feasibility is good score += 0.1 * self.metrics.feasibility_rate # Enough training data if self.metrics.n_trials_analyzed >= 50: score += 0.1 if self.metrics.n_trials_analyzed >= 100: score += 0.1 return min(1.0, max(0.0, score)) class AdaptiveMethodSelector: """ Recommends optimization method based on problem characteristics and metrics. The selector uses a scoring system to rank methods: - Each method starts with a base score - Scores are adjusted based on problem characteristics - Early metrics further refine the recommendation - NN quality metrics adjust confidence based on actual surrogate performance """ def __init__(self): self.profiler = ProblemProfiler() self.metrics_collector = EarlyMetricsCollector() self.nn_quality_assessor = NNQualityAssessor() # Method base scores (can be tuned based on historical performance) self.base_scores = { OptimizationMethod.PURE_FEA: 0.5, OptimizationMethod.HYBRID_LOOP: 0.6, OptimizationMethod.TURBO: 0.7, OptimizationMethod.GNN_FIELD: 0.4, } # Store last metrics for reporting self.last_nn_quality: Optional[NNQualityMetrics] = None self.last_early_metrics: Optional[EarlyMetrics] = None def recommend(self, config: dict, db_path: Path = None, early_metrics: EarlyMetrics = None, results_dir: Path = None) -> MethodRecommendation: """ Generate method recommendation. Args: config: Optimization config dict db_path: Optional path to existing study.db for early metrics early_metrics: Pre-computed early metrics (optional) results_dir: Optional path to 2_results directory for NN quality data Returns: MethodRecommendation with method, confidence, and parameters """ # Profile the problem profile = self.profiler.analyze(config) # Collect early metrics if database exists if db_path and db_path.exists() and early_metrics is None: early_metrics = self.metrics_collector.collect( db_path, profile.objective_names, profile.variable_names, config.get('constraints', []) ) # Collect NN quality metrics if results directory exists nn_quality = None if results_dir is None and db_path: results_dir = db_path.parent # study.db is typically in 2_results if results_dir and results_dir.exists() and early_metrics: nn_quality = self.nn_quality_assessor.collect( results_dir, profile.objective_names, early_metrics ) self.last_nn_quality = nn_quality # Store early_metrics for reporting self.last_early_metrics = early_metrics # Score each method (now includes NN quality) scores = self._score_methods(profile, early_metrics, nn_quality) # Sort by score ranked = sorted(scores.items(), key=lambda x: x[1]['score'], reverse=True) # Build recommendation best_method, best_info = ranked[0] recommendation = MethodRecommendation( method=best_method.value, confidence=min(1.0, best_info['score']), parameters=self._get_parameters(best_method, profile, early_metrics), reasoning=best_info['reason'], alternatives=[ { 'method': m.value, 'confidence': min(1.0, info['score']), 'reason': info['reason'] } for m, info in ranked[1:3] ], warnings=self._get_warnings(profile, early_metrics, nn_quality) ) return recommendation def _score_methods(self, profile: ProblemProfile, metrics: EarlyMetrics = None, nn_quality: NNQualityMetrics = None) -> Dict[OptimizationMethod, Dict]: """Score each method based on problem characteristics and NN quality.""" scores = {} for method in OptimizationMethod: score = self.base_scores[method] reasons = [] # === TURBO MODE === if method == OptimizationMethod.TURBO: # Good for: low-dimensional, smooth, sufficient budget, good NN quality if profile.n_variables <= 5: score += 0.15 reasons.append("low-dimensional design space") elif profile.n_variables > 10: score -= 0.2 reasons.append("high-dimensional (may struggle)") if profile.max_fea_trials >= 50: score += 0.1 reasons.append("sufficient FEA budget") else: score -= 0.15 reasons.append("limited FEA budget") if metrics and metrics.response_smoothness > 0.7: score += 0.15 reasons.append(f"smooth landscape ({metrics.response_smoothness:.0%})") elif metrics and metrics.response_smoothness < 0.4: score -= 0.2 reasons.append(f"rough landscape ({metrics.response_smoothness:.0%})") # NEW: NN Quality-based adjustments using relative thresholds if nn_quality and nn_quality.has_nn_data: if nn_quality.turbo_suitability > 0.8: score += 0.25 reasons.append(f"excellent NN quality ({nn_quality.turbo_suitability:.0%})") elif nn_quality.turbo_suitability > 0.5: score += 0.1 reasons.append(f"good NN quality ({nn_quality.turbo_suitability:.0%})") elif nn_quality.turbo_suitability < 0.3: score -= 0.25 reasons.append(f"poor NN quality ({nn_quality.turbo_suitability:.0%}) - use hybrid") # Per-objective warnings for high CV ratios for obj, cv_ratio in nn_quality.cv_ratios.items(): if cv_ratio > 2.0: score -= 0.1 reasons.append(f"{obj}: NN error >> variability") elif metrics and metrics.nn_accuracy and metrics.nn_accuracy > 0.9: score += 0.1 reasons.append(f"excellent NN fit ({metrics.nn_accuracy:.0%})") # === HYBRID LOOP === elif method == OptimizationMethod.HYBRID_LOOP: # Good for: moderate complexity, unknown landscape, need safety if 3 <= profile.n_variables <= 10: score += 0.1 reasons.append("moderate dimensionality") if metrics and 0.4 < metrics.response_smoothness < 0.8: score += 0.1 reasons.append("uncertain landscape - hybrid adapts") if profile.has_constraints and metrics and metrics.feasibility_rate < 0.9: score += 0.1 reasons.append("constrained problem - safer approach") if profile.max_fea_trials >= 30: score += 0.05 reasons.append("adequate budget for iterations") # NEW: NN Quality adjustments for hybrid if nn_quality and nn_quality.has_nn_data: if nn_quality.hybrid_suitability > 0.5: score += 0.15 reasons.append("NN adds value with periodic retraining") if nn_quality.turbo_suitability < 0.5: score += 0.1 reasons.append("NN quality suggests hybrid over turbo") # === PURE FEA === elif method == OptimizationMethod.PURE_FEA: # Good for: small budget, highly nonlinear, rough landscape if profile.max_fea_trials < 30: score += 0.2 reasons.append("limited budget - no NN overhead") if metrics and metrics.response_smoothness < 0.3: score += 0.2 reasons.append("rough landscape - NN unreliable") if profile.expected_nonlinearity == 'high': score += 0.15 reasons.append("highly nonlinear physics") if metrics and metrics.feasibility_rate < 0.5: score += 0.1 reasons.append("many infeasible designs - need accurate FEA") # NEW: NN Quality - if NN is truly poor, favor pure FEA if nn_quality and nn_quality.has_nn_data: if nn_quality.hybrid_suitability < 0.3: score += 0.2 reasons.append("NN quality too low - prefer FEA") # === GNN FIELD === elif method == OptimizationMethod.GNN_FIELD: # Good for: high-dimensional, need field visualization if profile.n_variables > 10: score += 0.2 reasons.append("high-dimensional - GNN handles well") # GNN is more advanced, only recommend if specifically needed if profile.n_variables <= 5: score -= 0.1 reasons.append("simple problem - MLP sufficient") # Compile reason string reason = "; ".join(reasons) if reasons else "default recommendation" scores[method] = {'score': score, 'reason': reason} return scores def _get_parameters(self, method: OptimizationMethod, profile: ProblemProfile, metrics: EarlyMetrics = None) -> Dict[str, Any]: """Generate recommended parameters for the selected method.""" params = {} if method == OptimizationMethod.TURBO: # Scale NN trials based on dimensionality base_nn_trials = 5000 if profile.n_variables <= 2: nn_trials = base_nn_trials elif profile.n_variables <= 5: nn_trials = base_nn_trials * 2 else: nn_trials = base_nn_trials * 3 params = { 'nn_trials': nn_trials, 'batch_size': 100, 'retrain_every': 10, 'epochs': 150 if metrics and metrics.n_trials_analyzed > 100 else 200 } elif method == OptimizationMethod.HYBRID_LOOP: params = { 'iterations': 5, 'nn_trials_per_iter': 500, 'validate_per_iter': 5, 'epochs': 300 } elif method == OptimizationMethod.PURE_FEA: # Choose sampler based on objectives if profile.is_multi_objective: sampler = 'NSGAIISampler' else: sampler = 'TPESampler' params = { 'sampler': sampler, 'n_trials': min(100, profile.max_fea_trials), 'timeout_per_trial': profile.fea_time_estimate } elif method == OptimizationMethod.GNN_FIELD: params = { 'model_type': 'parametric_gnn', 'initial_fea_trials': 100, 'nn_trials': 10000, 'epochs': 200 } return params def _get_warnings(self, profile: ProblemProfile, metrics: EarlyMetrics = None, nn_quality: NNQualityMetrics = None) -> List[str]: """Generate warnings about potential issues.""" warnings = [] if profile.n_variables > 10: warnings.append( f"High-dimensional problem ({profile.n_variables} variables) - " "consider dimensionality reduction or Latin Hypercube sampling" ) if profile.max_fea_trials < 20: warnings.append( f"Very limited FEA budget ({profile.max_fea_trials} trials) - " "neural acceleration may not have enough training data" ) if metrics and metrics.feasibility_rate < 0.5: warnings.append( f"Low feasibility rate ({metrics.feasibility_rate:.0%}) - " "consider relaxing constraints or narrowing design space" ) if metrics and metrics.response_smoothness < 0.3: warnings.append( f"Rough objective landscape detected - " "neural surrogate may have high prediction errors" ) # NEW: NN Quality warnings if nn_quality and nn_quality.has_nn_data: # Per-objective quality warnings for obj_name, cv_ratio in nn_quality.cv_ratios.items(): obj_type = nn_quality.objective_types.get(obj_name, 'smooth') nn_error = nn_quality.nn_errors.get(obj_name, 0) expected = nn_quality.expected_errors.get(obj_name, 5.0) if cv_ratio > 2.0: warnings.append( f"{obj_name}: NN error ({nn_error:.1f}%) >> variability - " f"NN not learning physics well for this {obj_type} objective" ) elif nn_error > expected * 1.5: warnings.append( f"{obj_name}: NN error ({nn_error:.1f}%) above expected ({expected:.0f}%) - " f"consider retraining or using hybrid mode" ) return warnings class RuntimeAdvisor: """ Monitors optimization runtime and suggests method pivots. Call check_pivot() periodically during optimization to get suggestions for method changes. """ def __init__(self, check_interval: int = 10): """ Args: check_interval: Check for pivots every N trials """ self.check_interval = check_interval self.history: List[RuntimeMetrics] = [] self.pivot_suggestions: List[Dict] = [] def update(self, metrics: RuntimeMetrics): """Add new runtime metrics to history.""" metrics.timestamp = datetime.now().isoformat() self.history.append(metrics) def check_pivot(self, current_method: str) -> Optional[Dict]: """ Check if a method pivot should be suggested. Args: current_method: Currently running method Returns: Pivot suggestion dict or None """ if len(self.history) < 2: return None latest = self.history[-1] previous = self.history[-2] suggestion = None # Check 1: NN accuracy declining if latest.nn_accuracy_trend == 'declining': if current_method == 'turbo': suggestion = { 'suggest_pivot': True, 'from': current_method, 'to': 'hybrid_loop', 'reason': 'NN accuracy declining - switch to hybrid for more frequent retraining', 'urgency': 'medium' } # Check 2: Pareto front stagnating if latest.pareto_growth_rate < 0.01 and previous.pareto_growth_rate < 0.01: suggestion = { 'suggest_pivot': True, 'from': current_method, 'to': 'increase_exploration', 'reason': 'Pareto front stagnating - consider increasing exploration', 'urgency': 'low' } # Check 3: High FEA failure rate if latest.fea_failure_rate > 0.2: if current_method in ['turbo', 'hybrid_loop']: suggestion = { 'suggest_pivot': True, 'from': current_method, 'to': 'pure_fea', 'reason': f'High FEA failure rate ({latest.fea_failure_rate:.0%}) - NN exploring invalid regions', 'urgency': 'high' } # Check 4: Diminishing returns if latest.improvement_rate < 0.001 and latest.trials_completed > 100: suggestion = { 'suggest_pivot': True, 'from': current_method, 'to': 'stop_early', 'reason': 'Diminishing returns - consider stopping optimization', 'urgency': 'low' } if suggestion: self.pivot_suggestions.append(suggestion) return suggestion def get_summary(self) -> Dict: """Get summary of runtime performance.""" if not self.history: return {} latest = self.history[-1] return { 'trials_completed': latest.trials_completed, 'pareto_size': latest.pareto_size, 'fea_time_mean': latest.fea_time_mean, 'fea_failure_rate': latest.fea_failure_rate, 'nn_accuracy': latest.nn_accuracy, 'pivot_suggestions_count': len(self.pivot_suggestions) } def print_recommendation(rec: MethodRecommendation, profile: ProblemProfile = None, nn_quality: NNQualityMetrics = None, early_metrics: EarlyMetrics = None): """Pretty-print a method recommendation with NN quality assessment.""" print("\n" + "=" * 70) print(" OPTIMIZATION METHOD ADVISOR") print("=" * 70) if profile: print("\nProblem Profile:") print(f" Variables: {profile.n_variables} ({', '.join(profile.variable_names)})") print(f" Objectives: {profile.n_objectives} ({', '.join(profile.objective_names)})") print(f" Constraints: {profile.n_constraints}") print(f" Max FEA budget: ~{profile.max_fea_trials} trials") # NN Quality Assessment Section if nn_quality and nn_quality.has_nn_data: print("\nNN Quality Assessment:") print(f" Validations analyzed: {nn_quality.n_validations}") print() # Build table header print(" | Objective | NN Error | CV | Ratio | Type | Quality |") print(" |---------------|----------|--------|-------|------------|---------|") for obj_name in nn_quality.nn_errors.keys(): nn_error = nn_quality.nn_errors.get(obj_name, 0) cv_ratio = nn_quality.cv_ratios.get(obj_name, 0) obj_type = nn_quality.objective_types.get(obj_name, 'smooth') # Get CV from early_metrics if available cv_pct = 0.0 if early_metrics and early_metrics.coefficient_of_variation: cv = early_metrics.coefficient_of_variation.get(obj_name, 0) cv_pct = cv * 100 # Convert to percentage # Quality indicator if cv_ratio < 0.5: quality = "✓ Great" elif cv_ratio < 1.0: quality = "✓ Good" elif cv_ratio < 2.0: quality = "~ OK" else: quality = "✗ Poor" # Format row print(f" | {obj_name[:13]:<13} | {nn_error:>6.1f}% | {cv_pct:>5.1f}% | {cv_ratio:>5.2f} | {obj_type:<10} | {quality:<7} |") print() print(f" Overall Quality: {nn_quality.overall_quality:.0%}") print(f" Turbo Suitability: {nn_quality.turbo_suitability:.0%}") print(f" Hybrid Suitability: {nn_quality.hybrid_suitability:.0%}") print("\n" + "-" * 70) print(f"\n RECOMMENDED: {rec.method.upper()}") print(f" Confidence: {rec.confidence:.0%}") print(f" Reason: {rec.reasoning}") print("\n Suggested parameters:") for key, value in rec.parameters.items(): print(f" --{key.replace('_', '-')}: {value}") if rec.alternatives: print("\n Alternatives:") for alt in rec.alternatives: print(f" - {alt['method']} ({alt['confidence']:.0%}): {alt['reason']}") if rec.warnings: print("\n Warnings:") for warning in rec.warnings: print(f" ! {warning}") print("\n" + "=" * 70) # Convenience function for quick use def recommend_method(config_path: Path, db_path: Path = None, results_dir: Path = None) -> Tuple[MethodRecommendation, 'AdaptiveMethodSelector']: """ Quick method recommendation from config file. Args: config_path: Path to optimization_config.json db_path: Optional path to existing study.db results_dir: Optional path to results directory (for NN quality assessment) Returns: Tuple of (MethodRecommendation, AdaptiveMethodSelector) The selector contains last_nn_quality and last_early_metrics for display """ with open(config_path) as f: config = json.load(f) selector = AdaptiveMethodSelector() rec = selector.recommend(config, db_path, early_metrics=None, results_dir=results_dir) return rec, selector if __name__ == "__main__": # Test with a sample config import sys if len(sys.argv) > 1: config_path = Path(sys.argv[1]) db_path = Path(sys.argv[2]) if len(sys.argv) > 2 else None # Infer results_dir from config_path location (typically in 1_setup) results_dir = None if config_path.parent.name == "1_setup": results_dir = config_path.parent.parent / "2_results" elif "2_results" in str(config_path): results_dir = config_path.parent rec, selector = recommend_method(config_path, db_path, results_dir) # Also get profile for display with open(config_path) as f: config = json.load(f) profiler = ProblemProfiler() profile = profiler.analyze(config) # Print with NN quality metrics if available print_recommendation( rec, profile, nn_quality=selector.last_nn_quality, early_metrics=selector.last_early_metrics ) else: print("Usage: python method_selector.py [db_path]")