# Audit: Hydrotech Beam Project Health — 2026-02-14

**Verdict:** CONDITIONAL PASS
**Posted to:** Discord #hydrotech-beam (channel 1472019487308910727)

## Key Findings
- 🔴 Mass = NaN on ALL 39 solved trials (fix exists in 580ed65, not re-run)
- 🔴 DOE not re-run since mass fix (3 days stale)
- 🟡 Solve success rate 76.5% (below 80% gate, but all "failures" are geo-prefilter — actual NX solve rate is 100%)
- 🟡 Phase 1 gate check failed (all criteria)
- 🟡 doe_summary.json still says 10mm constraint (should be 20mm per DEC-HB-012)
- 🟢 Documentation, code architecture, physics — all solid

## Blocker
Pull 580ed65 on dalidou → re-run DOE → verify mass values

## Next Review
After DOE re-run with clean mass data, review results before Phase 2 gate.